Tesla Owner's Final Appeal in Defamation Case Dismissed

[Legal Dispute] Ms. Zhang, the female Tesla owner who staged a protest on the vehicle roof, has had her retrial application rejected. All three levels of courts have ruled that her actions constituted defamation.

Core Development: Ms. Zhang’s Claim of 'Brake Failure' Lacks Factual Basis

The court stated that her 2021 rooftop protest at the Shanghai Auto Show exceeded the bounds of reasonable criticism and infringed upon Tesla's right to reputation. Mr. Feng, the organizer, was also found jointly liable for infringement due to his role in orchestrating the event and related online statements.

Key Details: Compensation of RMB 172,000 and Public Apology Required

Following the initial ruling in May 2024, the appellate court upheld the decision in July 2025. On June 17, 2026, the Shanghai High People's Court dismissed the retrial application, concluding the case.

Industry Impact: Consumer Rights Advocacy Must Adhere to Factual Boundaries

The court emphasized that even amid disputes over product quality, unsubstantiated allegations still incur liability for infringement, thereby establishing a clear legal boundary for consumer维权 actions in the industry.